Topology in Metric Spaces II





Topology in Metric Spaces — Illustrated Proofs


Claim: Open Ball is an Open Set

Let \((X,d)\) be a metric space. Then every open ball is open.

Proof. Fix \(x\in X\), \(r>0\), and let \(U=B_r(x)\).
If \(u\in U\), set \(\varepsilon=r-d(u,x)>0\). For any \(y\in B_\varepsilon(u)\),
the triangle inequality gives \(d(y,x)\le d(y,u)+d(u,x)<\varepsilon+d(u,x)=r\); hence \(y\in B_r(x)\). Thus about each \(u\in U\) there is a ball contained in \(U\), so \(U\) is open.

Proposition: Properties of the Induced Topology

Let \((X,d)\) be a metric space and \(\mathcal T\) its family of open sets. Then \(\emptyset,X\in\mathcal T\); \(\mathcal T\) is closed under arbitrary unions and finite intersections.

  1. \(\emptyset,X\in\mathcal T\). Trivial and vacuous.
  2. Arbitrary unions. If \(x\in\bigcup_i U_i\), pick \(U_j\ni x\). Since \(U_j\) is open, some ball about \(x\) lies in \(U_j\subseteq\bigcup_i U_i\).
  3. Finite intersections. If \(x\in U\cap V\), pick radii \(r,s\) with \(B_r(x)\subseteq U\), \(B_s(x)\subseteq V\). Then \(B_{\min\{r,s\}}(x)\subseteq U\cap V\).

Arbitrary union of opens is open \(\color{#8B0000}{U_1}\) \(\color{#1e6bd6}{U_2}\) \(\color{#2b7a2b}{U_3}\) \(x\) ball in the union

Finite intersections are open \(\color{#8B0000}{U}\) \(\color{#1e6bd6}{V}\) \(x\) ball in \(U\cap V\)

Left: at a point of the union, use the open set that already contains it. Right: in an intersection, shrink to the smaller radius.

Proposition: Metric Spaces are Hausdorff

If \(x\neq y\), let \(\delta=d(x,y)\), and set \(U=B_{\delta/2}(x)\), \(V=B_{\delta/2}(y)\). These are disjoint by the triangle inequality.

Disjoint balls of radius δ/2 \(x\) \(y\) \(U=B_{\delta/2}(x)\) \(V=B_{\delta/2}(y)\) \(\delta=d(x,y)\) \(\delta/2+\delta/2=\delta\)
If a point lay in both balls, the triangle inequality would force \(d(x,y)\lt\delta\), a contradiction.

Definition: Interior of a Set

For \(E\subseteq X\), the interior is \(E^\circ=\{x\in E:\exists r>0\ \text{with}\ B_r(x)\subseteq E\}\), i.e., the largest open set contained in \(E\).

Interior point \(x\in E^\circ\) \(B_r(x)\subset E\) \(E\)
Boundary point (not interior) \(y\notin E^\circ\) any ball meets \(E^c\)

Left: an interior point supports a small ball fully inside \(E\). Right: a boundary point cannot.